“‘There were unexpected difficulties,’ said the dark gray blur.”
Set not long after Ancillary Mercy, but following new characters, Provenance is a chance to look at a part of that universe outside Radch space. We follow Ingray, a foster-daughter of an important ‘politician’, trying to prove herself worthy of – literally – her mother’s name. Driven to extremes to beat her golden-boy brother, engineering a prison break – from an impossible-to-escape prison – is only the first step and she’s soon caught up in intrigue that affects at least three species and which may threaten her entire world’s sense of identity.
The Ancillary trilogy was on my top reads of last year, and I was hugely excited to revisit the universe. Of course, with such a background, it was always going to be tough for this to live up to – and for me, it doesn’t quite hit it. And yet, it’s still a good book – comparisons can be killer!
Ingray is okay as a main character, but to be honest she’s a bit, well… teenage? Prone to tears and a bit bumbling, she’s at the same time refreshingly different from the ‘strong female lead’, and somehow displaying a quieter strength even as you think she’s a bit lost. The story is a lot about politicking and jostling for position, and the weird ways in which we ‘prove’ our worth, which is made about as interesting as it can be but still feels a little small in comparison to some of the events of the previous books – even when we start bringing in intergalactic peace treaties.
So, while very very well-written, and still pretty fascinating, this is more of a “aren’t some alien species funny?” kind of a tale, not quite played for laughs but almost, rather than anything like a typical space-opera. It doesn’t hurt Leckie’s reputation one jot, but I did find myself thinking this was more of a ‘message’ book than a riveting story that needed telling, at times.
Hardback: 438 pages / 20 chapters
First published: 2017
Series: set in Imperial Radch universe, but not part of Ancillary series
Read from 18th February 2018
My rating: 8/10