Bone Silence – Alastair Reynolds

bone silence cover

“It had begun as a distant glimmering dot; now it was unmistakably a world.”

Following on from Revenger and Shadow Captain, we rejoin the Ness sisters in the final part of the trilogy. Usual warning that merely mentioning characters in the third instalment could be spoilers for who survives the first two, etc.

Fura and Adrana ran away from home, have survived horrors, and now are in charge of their own ship and free to pursue the questions that haunt them: what are quoins, really – seemingly more than mere currency. And why do Occupations (re-populating the solar system) happen with the odd irregularity that they do – is something responsible for starting them… or, ending them?

But the rest of the Congregation seems intent on blaming the Nesses for crimes they didn’t commit. Answers might prove a harder fight than they want…

From the get-go, I’ve enjoyed these books but not in the same way as Alastair Reynolds’ other, less-YA, work. The story is interest rather than gripping, the characters not entirely involving, somehow. Perhaps because the narration has shifted once again, from Fura in book one and Adrana in book two, we now get a third person narrative, highly necessary as the stories diverge.

Still, there was no way I wasn’t going to finish the trilogy, and hopefully get some answers. And we do, and they aren’t bad, and yet I didn’t feel entirely satisfied somehow. One ‘reveal’, about the alien race of Clackers, seems accepted by all based on evidence I wasn’t sure might not have meant something else – at least enough to provoke at least one character to questions? And on the bigger mysteries, we’ve scratched a surface but there’s clearly much, much more going on – and that’s almost more infuriating than knowing nothing.

It’s well-written, I don’t regret picking up the series, but tbh I’m not entirely sure I’d recommend it. Go read Revelation Space instead!

Hardback: 602 pages / 33 chapters
First published: 2020
Series: Revenger book 3 (of 3)
Read from 12th February – 8th March 2020

My rating: 6.5/10

The Pursuit of William Abbey – Claire North

pursuit of william abbey cover

“The truth-speaker was tall as a stretcher, thin as a rifle.”

William Abbey is a young doctor working in Africa – a punishment for pursuing the wrong girl, in a very Victorian fashion – when he sees a native boy lynched. Shocked by the sight but unwilling to intervene, William is cursed by the boy’s mother. For the rest of his days, he will be followed by a shadow; if it reaches him, someone he loves will die. And so William runs, for the shadow only ever walks at a fixed pace. He can escape it for a while, but he can never stop.

He discovers others with the same condition – but, not all of them view it as a curse. For, along with the fear comes a gift. The closer the shadow gets, the more William can read the truth in men’s hearts. This makes him a valuable commodity to some, and it’s not long before he’s made an offer: assistance outpacing the shade, and in return he’ll spy for his country.

I’ve reviewed several of Claire North’s books, and I’ve said before I find them very hit (e.g. the amazing First Fifteen Lives of Harry August) or miss (e.g. 84K), although always well written and always intriguing enough to make trying the next one a risk worth taking. I’m pleased to report TPoWA falls into the ‘hit’ category for me.

William is not a hero as such. He bumbles through life, he’s used, he’s afraid. But he’s also increasingly aware of his own flaws, and slowly, slowly moves towards a resolution to the tangle he finds himself in.

A fairly hefty dose of social commentary seems to run through North’s work; here: is it really ‘less bad’ to be a bystander to terrible events? I’m not convinced. I’ve just finished renewing my first aid training, and the first rule is “See to your own safety first”. It felt a bit unfair that William is the one cursed, for not risking himself, and not one of the men directly involved in the lynching. I guess that’s part of the debate.

It continues with a more obvious “just following orders” kind of moralising. William reports back to his superiors, but doesn’t get involved in the consequences. Then he meets someone else with his ‘gift’, and we also get to ask, do the ends ever/always justify the means?

All of which makes it sound like a very heavy read, and it’s not too bad, honestly! The telling is split between a nurse in a WWI front line hospital, who meets the older Dr Abbey, and the gent himself telling his impossible tale. I can see why other reviewers felt they couldn’t connect with the lead, as he’s a passive pawn in most of the tale. But, stick with it.

I haven’t seen the movie It Follows, although that’s what this first reminded me of, then a supernatural Victorian anti-Bond. It’s creepy, but not horror. Rather, the sheer intrigue kept me reading, and I’m glad I did.

Hardback: 420 pages / 78 chapters
First published: 2019
Series: none
Read from 9th-15th December 2019

My rating: 8/10

Wundersmith: The Calling of Morrigan Crow – Jessica Townsend

wundersmith cover

“Morrigan Crow leapt from the Brolly Rail, teeth chattering, hands frozen around the end of her oilskin umbrella.”

(As per usual, vague spoilers for events in book 1 just by mention of how the second starts, and with what characters – read on at your peril!)

Following from the events in The Trials of Morrigan Crowour titular heroine is settling into life in the wonderful land of Nevermoor. We ended book 1 with her acceptance into the Wundrous Society, so now her education begins. But, the residents of Nevermoor have been taught to fear Wundersmiths, and Morrigan’s teachers are determined to school her in the evils committed by her predecessors. Can Morrigan prove that she belongs in WunSoc? Will her secret get out – and make her former life as a ‘cursed’ child seem pleasant in comparison?

And in the wider community, are a series of mysterious disappearances linked? The new WunSoc class are discovering new marvels of their town, twisty lanes and secret railroads. But they also have to face dark myths, creatures made out of old bones, and a horrible market that wouldn’t hesitate to sell sentient ‘wunimals’, or a person’s ‘knack’…!

Although aimed at a younger audience (than me ;)) I absolutely loved the first book in this series. The mix of magic and wonder and a healthy dollop of danger makes for a great adventure. Book 2 picks that up excellently, growing the story organically and still making Nevermoor feel very much like a place I’d like to visit.

Bring on book 3 – and 4, 5, and oh so many more?! Fingers crossed 🙂

Library Paperback: 404 pages / 29 chapters
First published: 2018
Series: Nevermoor book 2
Read from 9th-16th November 2019

My rating: 8/10

Ninth House – Leigh Bardugo

ninth house cover

“By the time Alex managed to get the blood out of her good wool coat, it was too warm to wear it.”

Alex Stern has a secret. It’s driven her to dark places in her life, but now she has the chance at a new life, a fresh start. Her special skills have caught the eye of the Lethe society, a secret group in Yale University, tasked with watching the other secret societies. Each of these not only spawns rich and powerful alumni, in fields from Wall Street to Hollywood to Washington, but uses occult arts to get there. Reading entrails to predict the stockmarket, glamours and potions – how far can things go before backfiring?

I’ve adored Leigh Bardugo’s work since stumbling across Six of Crows, and with this she makes her first foray into adult fiction. And it is most definitely not YA: it’s dark and gritty, and a few scenes bear possible ‘trigger warnings’ – the attempted rape of a pre-teen had me put the book down for a little bit, not least because the trauma comes across strongly in the writing.

It’s still very worth it, however. Bardugo is herself a Yale alumni, and the sense of cliques within cliques, of a whole town thrown that bit out of whack, really adds to the story of Alex’s attempts to learn about the occult, train to be the watcher, as well as keeping up with her studies. As for a social life – well, she’d settle for just not alienating her roomates completely!

The story is told in flashbacks, building a huge sense of mystery. What dark things happened to Alex before we meet her? And the other major players? Layers of mystery kept me absolutely gripped, and that’s even before we get to the murder…!

Very recommended, with that once warning: it gets dark. But I am delighted that this is the first in a new series – I want more!!

Hardback: 450 pages / 32 chapters
First published: 2019
Series: Alex Stern book 1 (woo! More to come!! 🙂 )
Read from 19th October – 9th November 2019

My rating: 9/10

Shadow Captain – Alastair Reynolds

Shadow Captain cover

“‘Tell me what you think you saw.'”

Following on immediately from the events in Revenger, usual warning that even mentioning characters that made it to the sequel can be a kind of spoiler. And my opening lines are definitely book 1 spoilers…!

Okay with that? Then read on!

Having won and renamed The Revenger, the Ness sisters are free of Bosa Sennen – or, are they? Did Adrana’s time being groomed as her successor leave its mark or did Arafura’s rescue come in time? And what of Fura – she had to change to beat the galaxy’s biggest evil, does that leave an even bigger mark? The two have clearly grown up – it’s tough to remember they’re supposed to be 18-ish, even more to remember Adrana is the elder – and their objectives have changed. Not wholly through choice, though, as escaping the shadow of Bosa is harder than they thought…

I’d reread Revenger in preparation for this, and as such it came as a bit of a surprise to find the first person narrative switching from Fura to Adrana. In fact, I found it so hard to switch mental gears, that I put the book down and read something else first!

It is clear from the story why the viewpoint had to change, but it takes a while to feel not-weird. Whether that was my brain adjusting, or the writing developing a more distinctive tone – not sure.

It also helps immensely when the action gets going, and by the time the crew land on-world the descriptions of the decaying, corrupt place were spot on.

Overall, there are enough mysteries to keep you guessing – with a few more explanations for some of the world-building, like the genesis of the Congregation (they did *what* to Earth, Mars, et al?!) – but none more so than wondering about the motivations of the characters.

Still, as enjoyable as this was, for me it doesn’t live up to Alastair Reynolds’ other work. The difference is writing for (I believe) more a YA audience, and something in the tone just didn’t work as well for me. I will look out for the third volume of the trilogy, though, as I’m intrigued enough to see where the Ness sisters end their story…!

Hardback: 488 pages / 25 chapters
First published: 2019
Series: Revenger book 2
Read from 1st September – 10th October 2019

My rating: 7/10

The October Man – Ben Aaronovitch

october man cover

“In late September, as the nights close in, a strange madness possesses my father.

After seven books following PC Peter Grant in London, Ben Aaronovitch takes a slight detour with this novel. we are introduced to Tobias winter, Peter’s German counterpart, sent to the town of Trier to investigate – you guessed it – somewhat strange goings on.

A body has been found in a field belonging to an old, but small vinery. It’s coated with mould – a fungus of the same kind used to deliberately infect the grapes to make a sweeter wine. The vinery is close to the river Kyll, and indeed the current owner’s grandfather would leave offerings to the river goddess… sound familiar?

Like the previous novella in the series (The Furthest Station), I enjoyed the way the shorter format kept things focused on the one story. It still has many twists and turns, not being quite as tight as I expected, but still intriguing.

Tobias Winter is basically Peter Grant with a few different words in his vocab. Taking any section without specific identifier, I think the narration would be indistinguishable from Grant’s street smart, slightly sarcastic tone. Which is no bad thing, but still.

While I overall enjoyed the story a great deal, I think introducing new characters, new location, and a new organisation is perhaps a bit much to ask for a sub-200-page novella.

Still very worth the read, though, for fans if maybe not newcomers to the series. It is interesting to see the Rivers of London series branching out, and I’d love to see even more – but, I think perhaps it’d only really work if the voice was as distinctive as the new region?

Hardback: 180 pages / 13 chapters
First published: 2019
Series: PC Peter Grant / Rivers of London book 7.5
Read from 25th-30th July 2019

My rating: 8/10

Outer Order Inner Calm – Gretchen Rubin

outer order cover

I’ve been a fan of Gretchen Rubin since The Happiness Diary, and so her take on the current mania for decluttering – something I’m in need of doing rather a lot of post-move! – was always going to intrigue me.

There’s no overt backlash against The Life Changing Magic of Tidying Up and Marie Kondo (indeed, the book is mentioned near the end), rather this is a gentle “Some things work for some people, but what you want is what will make YOU happy.” This is unsurprising: her last book was The Four Tendencies, all about different personality types reacting to things very differently.

There is some good advice to be had in these pages, but to be honest I was a bit disappointed by the presentation. It’s not a narrative, just a collection of snippets and quotes that I felt like I’d read most of it already on her blog. And while the advice is perfectly fine, indeed very good in some instances, the brevity and style just made me feel like this was a low-effort money spinner, which was unexpected.

I’m not sure what else I wanted from the topic. It’s actually good that the subject matter isn’t drawn out just to make a bigger book. And yet… I dunno. Perhaps if anything had felt like more of a useful tip rather than a random musing on organisation?

As a collection of tips and a few motivational quotes, it’s fine. In terms of actually being inspired to go declutter – meh.

Hardback: 208 pages
First published: 2019
Series: none
Read from 24th-30th March 2019

My rating: 6/10